Costory vs Craftybase (now Stocksmith) · Shopify
A Craftybase alternative that runs inside your Shopify admin
Craftybase is now called Stocksmith: the same software, team and prices, renamed on 1 July 2026. Costory is a Craftybase alternative for brands that sell on Shopify: it works out each product’s cost from its recipe inside the Shopify admin, writes it to Cost per item and sets prices by margin, with a free plan for up to 10 products.
Free for up to 10 products · 14-day trial on paid plans
Updated
| Costory | Stocksmith (Craftybase) | |
|---|---|---|
| Runs | Inside the Shopify admin | Separate web app |
| Channels | Shopify | Shopify, Etsy, Amazon, Faire and 4 more |
| Shopify Cost per item | Written per variant | Not described |
| Prices from cost | Price rules set Shopify prices | Suggested prices (pricing guidance) |
| Free plan | Up to 10 products | No, 14-day trial |
| Paid plans | $12.99 – $99 / month | $20 – $349 / month |
Craftybase became Stocksmith on 1 July 2026; its product, data and pricing stayed the same. For a brand that sells on Shopify, Costory is a Craftybase alternative that runs inside the Shopify admin: it writes recipe costs to Cost per item and keeps prices in line with your margin, at $0 – $99 a month. Stocksmith is a separate web app for small manufacturers that sell on several channels (Shopify, Etsy, Amazon, Faire and more), priced at $20 – $349 a month and sized by order lines. Choose Stocksmith for one manufacturing inventory across many channels and for accounting reports; choose Costory if Shopify is where you sell and you want costs and prices kept current there.
Is Craftybase now Stocksmith?
Yes: Craftybase was renamed Stocksmith on 1 July 2026, after 15 years under the old name. The announcement by co-founder Nicole Pascoe says accounts, data, recipes, integrations, pricing and plans stayed as they were, and that the company was not sold: Craftybase has been run by Stocksmith Pty Ltd, an Australian company incorporated in 2013, and the product now carries the company’s name.
craftybase.com now redirects to stocksmith.io, and the Shopify App Store lists the app as “Stocksmith Inventory & Sync”, on the App Store since 25 November 2022. A search for Craftybase therefore lands on Stocksmith, and everything this page says about Stocksmith applies to Craftybase as well. Costory is a separate app by a different developer, with no link to either name.
| Old name | Craftybase, launched in 2011 |
|---|---|
| New name | Stocksmith, since 1 July 2026 |
| Company | Stocksmith Pty Ltd, Newcastle, Australia |
| Website | stocksmith.io (craftybase.com redirects there) |
| Shopify App Store | Stocksmith Inventory & Sync |
| What changed | The name, the website and the billing descriptor on card statements |
| What stayed | Software, data, integrations, pricing, plans and team |
Costory vs Stocksmith (Craftybase): feature comparison
Stocksmith is a manufacturing and inventory system that connects many sales channels; Costory is a Shopify app for recipe cost, Shopify prices and ingredient stock. The table compares them line by line, with Stocksmith’s facts taken from its site, help center and Shopify App Store listing on 20 November 2026.
| Costory | Stocksmith (formerly Craftybase) | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | Inside the Shopify admin, installed from the Shopify App Store; no separate account | A separate web app (app.stocksmith.io) that connects to your Shopify store |
| Sales channels | Shopify only | Shopify, Etsy, Amazon, Faire, WooCommerce, Square, Wix and Squarespace (Amazon on Business and Growth) |
| Recipe and BOM costing | Recipes with units, packs, waste % and yield; semi-finished goods (Starter and up) and products inside products | Multi-level bills of materials with sub-assemblies, as many levels deep as needed |
| Labor and overhead | Labor lines with roles and hourly rates; overhead as a %, a fixed amount per item, or monthly expenses ÷ planned quantity (every plan) | Labor and overhead allocated per product |
| Writes Shopify’s Cost per item | Yes, for every variant, on every plan | Not described; cost and margin appear in Stocksmith’s own reports, and COGS journals can go to QuickBooks on its Growth plan |
| Price rules | Markup, margin, cost plus, tiered margin and formulas, .99 endings, minimum margin; proposals and automatic mode on Starter and up; History with one-click rollback | Pricing guidance: a suggested price per pricing tier from a markup %; setting Shopify prices from cost is not described |
| Ingredient and material stock | Growth and Pro: deducted by Shopify orders or by production batches | Materials, components and finished goods; materials deducted when a production run is recorded |
| Stock in Shopify | Growth and Pro: made-to-order products show how many the ingredients can make; batches and purchases add finished stock | Stock push to Shopify on Indie and up (by hand on Indie; Auto-Push on Business and Growth) |
| Purchases and suppliers | Growth and Pro: purchase orders, receiving, delivery costs split across lines, write-offs, stock counts, reorder points | Purchase orders, supplier records, reorder points, stocktaking |
| Lots and expiry dates | Pro: lots with expiry dates, FEFO, warnings before expiry | Indie and up: batch and lot tracking, expiry dates, traceability reports |
| Accounting and tax | Profit reports by product and by order; stock valuation on Growth and Pro; no accounting integration | COGS and inventory valuation reports, a Schedule C guidance report; QuickBooks: purchase orders as bills on every plan, COGS journals on Growth (Xero listed as coming soon) |
| Team | Staff roles on Pro | Unlimited users from Studio; user roles from Indie |
| Free plan | Yes: up to 10 products with recipes | No |
| Free trial | 14 days on paid plans | 14 days on every plan, no credit card |
| Price | $0, $12.99, $39 or $99 a month, billed by Shopify in USD | From $20 to $349 a month on stocksmith.io, about 17% less billed annually; from $49 a month on the Shopify App Store |
| The plan depends on | Products with recipes and features | Order lines a month (250, 1,000, 5,000, 5,000+) and features |
| Track record | On the Shopify App Store since November 2026 | Craftybase since 2011; on the Shopify App Store since November 2022 |
“Not described” means we found no such feature on Stocksmith’s site, help center or App Store listing on 20 November 2026. Features change; check their pages before you decide.
How do Craftybase and Costory work with Shopify?
Stocksmith pulls your Shopify orders into its own app and works out cost and margin there; Costory works the other way round and writes cost, and if you want price, into Shopify itself.
Stocksmith with Shopify
- Pulls Shopify products, variants, orders and fees into Stocksmith.
- Deducts finished goods, and materials through the bill of materials.
- Pushes stock levels back to Shopify on Indie and up.
- Shows COGS and margin per order in its own reports.
- Suggests prices from markups; its help center calls this guidance.
Costory in Shopify
- Writes each variant’s recipe cost to Cost per item, so Shopify’s own profit and margin reports use it.
- Price rules propose or apply new Shopify prices when a cost changes.
- Deducts ingredients by Shopify orders and keeps Shopify stock of made-to-order products in line with them (Growth and Pro).
- Opens from Apps in your Shopify admin, with no second login.
- Reads orders only to deduct ingredients and calculate profit; it does not read customer names, emails or addresses.
Worked example: chocolate goes from $14 to $16 per kg
A brownie box costs $6.12 to make from five ingredients, and 200 g of it is dark chocolate. When the supplier raises chocolate from $14 to $16 per kg, Costory recalculates the box, writes the new Cost per item to Shopify and proposes a new price by the rule ending(margin(cost, 55%), 0.99):
| Before | After | |
|---|---|---|
| Chocolate line (200 g) | $2.80 | $3.20 |
| Cost per item in Shopify | $6.12 | $6.52 |
| Margin at $13.99 | 56% | 53% |
| Price by the rule | $13.99 | $14.99 |
| Margin at the rule price | 56% | 57% |
cost = $6.12 − $2.80 + 0.200 kg × $16.00 = $6.52
margin(cost, 55%) = $6.52 ÷ (1 − 0.55) = $14.49 → ending .99 = $14.99
On Starter and up the $14.99 waits in Proposals with the margin before and after, or goes to Shopify on its own in automatic mode; on Free you apply it on the product page. Every change is logged in History with one-click rollback. More in margin-based pricing and Shopify COGS.
How much does Craftybase (Stocksmith) cost compared with Costory?
At list prices checked on 20 November 2026, Stocksmith costs $20 – $349 a month and Costory $0 – $99 a month. Stocksmith plans grow with order lines a month (each product in an order is one line); Costory plans grow with products and features, and order volume does not change the plan.
| Plan | Billed monthly | Billed annually | Order lines a month | What it adds |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pro | from $20 | not listed | not listed; one sales channel | Inventory and cost tracking for a single channel with “very low order volume” |
| Studio | $49 | $490 ($41 / month) | 250 | Multi-user inventory and recipe management, unlimited sales channels |
| Indie | $99 | $990 ($83 / month) | 1,000 | Batch and lot tracking, traceability reports, user roles, stock push to channels by hand |
| Business | $199 | $1,990 ($166 / month) | 5,000 | Automatic stock sync, production scheduling, Amazon integration |
| Growth | $349 | $3,490 ($291 / month) | 5,000+ | QuickBooks inventory sync, priority support |
Prices in USD. Pro is named only in the FAQ of the pricing page (“starts at $20/mo”); Stocksmith’s feature pages say plans start from $24 a month. The Shopify App Store listing shows Studio, Indie, Business and Growth at $49, $99, $199 and $349 a month, “from $49/month”, and is the source of Studio’s 250 order lines and $490 a year; stocksmith.io lists Studio at $41 a month billed annually.
| Plan | Price | What it includes |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Up to 10 products with recipes and 1 price rule |
| Starter | $12.99 / month | 150 products, price proposals and automatic mode |
| Growth | $39 / month | Unlimited products, ingredient stock deducted by orders |
| Pro | $99 / month | Lots, locations, currencies, markets, Flow and API |
Worked example: a year for a Shopify-only maker
Take a maker who sells only on Shopify, has 60 products and about 600 order lines a month, and wants to track ingredient stock as well as costs.
- Stocksmith: Studio includes 250 order lines a month (App Store listing) and Pro is meant for “very low order volume”, so 600 lines lands on Indie: 12 × $99 = $1,188 a year billed monthly, or $990 billed annually.
- Costory: 60 products is over the Free limit of 10, and ingredient stock is on Growth: 12 × $39 = $468 a year. More orders do not move the plan.
Indie also includes things Costory Growth does not: other sales channels, lot tracking and traceability reports. Costory has lots with expiry dates on Pro, at $99 a month. See Costory’s plans.
Stocksmith or Costory: which one fits your business?
Stocksmith fits a maker who runs production across several sales channels; Costory fits a brand that sells on Shopify and wants its costs and prices right there.
Choose Stocksmith (Craftybase) if…
- You sell on Etsy, Amazon, Faire, WooCommerce, Square, Wix or Squarespace next to Shopify and need one stock count across them.
- You want a production record outside Shopify: runs with a material audit trail, production scheduling on Business and Growth, lot traceability reports from Indie.
- Your accountant wants COGS and inventory valuation reports, a Schedule C guidance report (US sole proprietors) or QuickBooks sync.
- You need several users from the start: Studio and up have unlimited users.
- You want a long track record: Craftybase has been around since 2011.
Choose Costory if…
- Shopify is where you sell, and you want to work in the Shopify admin without another login.
- You want Shopify’s Cost per item, and the profit and margin reports built on it, to follow your recipes when ingredient prices change.
- You want prices set by rules: margin, markup, cost plus or tiers, .99 endings, a minimum margin and a maximum change, with proposals before anything changes.
- You price sizes from one recipe with option modifiers (S ×0.6, L ×1.5, Starter and up) and count waste per ingredient.
- You want to start free with up to 10 products, then $12.99 a month for up to 150.
What Costory does not do
- Other sales channels. Only Shopify orders deduct stock and count in reports.
- Accounting. No QuickBooks or Xero sync and no tax forms; reports cover profit by product and by order, and stock value on Growth and Pro.
- Production scheduling. Costory records batches (Growth) and shows demand by delivery date (Pro), but has no production calendar.
- A long history. Costory has been on the Shopify App Store since November 2026.
Makers of candles, soap, jewelry and other handmade goods can read more on Costory for handmade brands, and stock features on inventory and purchasing and batch and expiry tracking. If you are also weighing a manufacturing system with production planning, see the Katana alternative comparison.
How to switch from Craftybase or Stocksmith to Costory
You can move materials and recipes from Stocksmith to Costory with two CSV files: export them, rename a few columns and import them as ingredients and recipes. Your products and variants already come from Shopify, so there is nothing to recreate.
- Install Costory from the Shopify App Store. It starts on Free; a paid plan starts with a 14-day trial, so you can run both apps side by side and compare costs before you cancel anything.
- Export your materials from Stocksmith: on the Materials list, the download icon in the pagination bar exports a CSV file, which arrives under the bell icon (Notifications). Rename its columns as below and upload it in Costory under Import ingredients.
- Export your recipes the same way from the Recipes list, rename the columns and upload the file under Import recipes. Rows are matched to Shopify variants by SKU.
- Add what the files do not carry: the recipe yield, labor lines (Stocksmith’s Manufacturing Minutes × an hourly rate), products inside products and overhead rules.
- Check and price. Open a few products in “How it’s calculated”, then create a price rule. In the “with confirmation” mode (Starter and up) it lists proposals with the margin before and after, and no Shopify price changes until you apply them.
| Stocksmith export | Costory import | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Materials → Import ingredients | ||
| Name | Ingredient | Required; “Name” is also read as is; a new name adds an ingredient |
| Category | Category | A category that does not exist yet is added |
| Tracking Unit | Unit | mg, g, kg, ml, l, mm, cm, m, cm2, m2 or pcs |
| Actual Unit Cost (or Unit Cost) | Price | The price of one Tracking Unit; a decimal comma or dot both work |
| Stock On Hand | In stock | With stock tracking (Growth and Pro); a plain number is read in the Unit, or add a unit or pack: 12 lb |
| Low Stock Limit | Minimum stock | With stock tracking (Growth and Pro); read the same way |
| Recipes → Import recipes | ||
| Product SKU | SKU | The SKU of the Shopify variant |
| Material Name | Ingredient | The ingredient’s name as imported above |
| Material Quantity | Quantity | Per batch of Batch Quantity units: divide by it, or set the same yield on the recipe |
Ounces and pounds. Costory’s units are metric plus pieces. For a material bought by the pound, put g in Unit, lb = 453.59 g | oz = 28.35 g in Packs and lb in Price per: the price per pound then works as it is, and recipe rows can use oz as their unit. Stock numbers are read in grams unless you add the pack, as in 12 lb.
Sources, checked November 2026
Every Stocksmith and Craftybase fact on this page comes from these pages, read on 20 November 2026. Costory facts come from the app itself and its pricing page.
- Craftybase is becoming Stocksmith: the rename, its date and what stayed the same
- Stocksmith pricing: plans, prices, order lines and features by plan
- Stocksmith Inventory & Sync on the Shopify App Store: App Store prices, trial, developer and launch date
- Stocksmith integrations: sales channels, QuickBooks and Xero
- Stocksmith QuickBooks integration: purchase orders as bills on every plan, COGS journals on Growth
- Stocksmith Shopify integration: order sync and stock push
- Stocksmith features: bills of materials, batch production, costing and reports
- Stocksmith lot tracking: lots and expiry dates from Indie
- About pricing guidance: suggested prices from markups per pricing tier
- Pushing stock updates to Shopify: stock push by plan
- About the Schedule C Guidance report
- Exporting materials and Exporting your recipes: the CSV columns used for switching
Questions about Craftybase, Stocksmith and Costory
Is Craftybase the same as Stocksmith?
Yes. Craftybase was renamed Stocksmith on 1 July 2026, and its announcement says the software, data, pricing and team stayed the same. craftybase.com now redirects to stocksmith.io, and the Shopify App Store lists the app as Stocksmith Inventory & Sync. It is run by Stocksmith Pty Ltd, the Australian company behind Craftybase.
Does Craftybase (Stocksmith) work with Shopify?
Yes. Stocksmith is a separate web app that connects to a Shopify store: it pulls products, orders and fees, deducts stock through bills of materials, and pushes stock levels back to Shopify on its Indie plan and up. It connects Etsy, Amazon, Faire, WooCommerce, Square, Wix and Squarespace as well. Costory works only with Shopify, inside the Shopify admin.
Is there a free alternative to Craftybase for Shopify?
Costory has a free plan: recipes and costs for up to 10 products, Cost per item sync, one price rule applied by hand on the product page, and profit reports for the last 30 days. Stocksmith has no free plan; each of its plans starts with a 14-day free trial without a credit card. Costory’s paid plans are $12.99, $39 and $99 a month, each with a 14-day trial.
Can Costory replace Craftybase if I also sell on Etsy or Amazon?
Not fully. Costory reads only Shopify orders, so Etsy, Amazon or Faire sales do not deduct ingredient stock or appear in its profit reports. If several channels draw from one stock, Stocksmith covers that case. If Shopify is your main or only channel, Costory covers costs, prices and ingredient stock there.
How do I move my materials and recipes from Craftybase to Costory?
Export the materials list and the recipe list from Stocksmith as CSV files, rename a few columns, and import them in Costory as ingredients and recipes. Ingredients need a name, a unit and a price; recipe rows are matched to Shopify variants by SKU. Recipe yield, labor lines and products inside products are set in the app after the import.
Does Costory have accounting or tax reports like Craftybase?
No. Costory has profit reports by product and by order, and a stock valuation report on Growth and Pro, but no accounting integrations and no tax forms. Stocksmith has COGS and inventory valuation reports, a Schedule C guidance report for US sole proprietors, and QuickBooks sync: purchase orders as bills on every plan, COGS journals on its Growth plan. If your books depend on those, Stocksmith or your accounting software keeps that job.
Which costs less, Costory or Stocksmith?
At list prices checked on 20 November 2026, Costory costs $0 – $99 a month and Stocksmith $20 – $349 a month, or from $49 a month on the Shopify App Store. Stocksmith plans grow with order lines a month, while Costory plans depend on products with recipes and features, not on orders. A multi-channel business pays Stocksmith for channels Costory does not connect.
Related
Katana alternative
Costory vs Katana: recipe costs, margin-based prices and ingredient stock inside Shopify, next to a full cloud inventory and manufacturing system.
Learn more →Handmade brands
Price handmade jewelry, apparel, decor and prints from materials, labor time and overhead, variant by variant.
Learn more →Shopify COGS
Cost per item calculated from each recipe and kept current when ingredient prices change.
Learn more →Keep your Shopify costs and prices in step with your recipes.
Free for up to 10 products. Paid plans start with a 14-day trial.
Install free on Shopify